People who need an abortion, need an abortion

“‘Some Say,’ Some Said”

The right to life ends at birth.

DC insider gossip rag Der Tiger Beat auf dem Potomac (thanks Charlie with an assist from MPS patron saint Watertiger) has a stupid article up (hard to believe, I know) in the category of Dems Are Terrible At Messaging (hard to believe, I know):

When Texas last week became the first state in nearly 50 years to ban abortions early in pregnancy, President Joe Biden, senior Democrats in Congress and the liberal members of the Supreme Court swiftly condemned the move, with Biden calling the law “an unprecedented assault on a woman’s constitutional rights” and Speaker Nancy Pelosi declaring the high court’s refusal to block it “a disrespect of all women.”

In a meeting with abortion rights groups on Thursday, Vice President Kamala Harris said, “The right of women to make decisions about their own bodies is not negotiable.”

So far, so good. So what’s the beef?

Yet many of the activists and clinics fighting the Texas law and similar restrictions around the country are taking pains to avoid gender-specific words such as “woman” and “women” — instead warning that “patients,” “Texans” and “people who need abortions” are being harmed…

…The younger and more diverse advocates pushing for more gender-neutral language argue that describing abortion rights solely as a women’s issue marginalizes the trans and non-binary people who want to terminate a pregnancy, and say being more inclusive helps build stronger political coalitions to take on the right.

And we note, as usual, that Tiger Beat is not citing anyone in these claims, and it raises the specter of the Defund The Police message: Right policy, bad message. This story (if true, and Politico does not have a great track record) also makes the case that this is wedge issue between generations of the Left and you can practically see the GOP strategists dancing a jig:

“What is the end goal here? Is the end goal actually winning, or is it just using the right language at that moment and winning is apparently not a priority?” said the advocate, who asked not to be named in discussing internal deliberations.

Tiger Beat does cite Reps. Cori Bush and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who have spoken and posted on social media about the need to protect “birthing people” and “menstruating people.” And I am not kidding. That’s the message that TBotP is claiming the Left is going to use, or some version of it.

May I modestly suggest: People who need an abortion, need an abortion.

I’m OK with ambiguity on this, I think the vast majority of Americans generally accept that women are people. I say that abortion is a human right. I do not think that this ambiguity erases trans people, it includes them.

“Obviously, ipso facto, it’s an attack on women,” said former Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) of Texas’ law and those like it. “We don’t have to say that, because who has babies? Women.”

Yet Boxer conceded that while she views the abortion bans primarily as an affront to women, she’s open to arguments that it also affects others.

“Whether you say A, B, C or D — get rid of the law,” she said. “That’s the most important thing.”

I’m totally with Barbara Boxer on this. Getting rid of the law is the point.

Who this ambiguity excludes is Tucker Carlson and Sean Hannity and their hateful ilk who cannot go onto their nightly shows and bellow about political correctness and trans people and rile-up Possum Hollar (who incidentally is in favor of abortions; over 70% of the country is in favor of abortion rights).

I’m not sure what Politico’s game is here, but I feel pretty certain that this is agitprop, only because they hardly have anyone on record.

As regular readers know, I’m a huge defender of trans people, applying Maya Angelou’s axiom “When someone tells you who they are, believe them the first time.” Not everyone agrees with me, but I think all Scissorheads agree that People who need an abortion, need an abortion.

This entry was posted in Choice, Forced Birth, sexism, War on Women. Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to People who need an abortion, need an abortion

  1. MDavis says:

    The whole current trans debate seems to me to be an extremely muddy area.
    One thing that stands out, for me, is the involvement of the medical system. There is a buck to be made on gender reassignment, and where there is a buck to be made the opportunity won’t be passed up by a significant portion of that community.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Ten Bears says:

    One of the few times I’ve been called “liberal” was when I told an assshole to shut the fuck up, doesn’t matter his or my personal opinion it’s none of our goddamned business what a woman does with her body.

    He didn’t think he could be hit that hard …

    Liked by 1 person

  3. roket says:

    Wisht I was a fly on the wall during the brainstorming session where they came up with this gem.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. lisahgolden says:

    Some people say Politico is decent journalism, too. Ha.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. mr perfect says:

    To sum what TBotP (suspiciously looks like an anagram of Politico) is saying is, “What about the Kaitlin Jenners of America Dems and Libs, don’t they deserve the right to abortion too?” What a hard hitting news organization!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Scottiestoybox says:

    Hello Tengrain. This is semantics. Words have meanings because the majority uses the assigned meanings. Those assigned meanings can and sometimes quickly do change with the times. If you have an unviable fetus inside you and you want it out, I don’t care if you call yourself a tricycle and identify as a furry elf, you should have a right to get the thing out. I agree with you if you need one, you get one. All my life I grew up hearing people say what a real man was, and they were all wrong. I am not going to have the same conversation about what is a real women. Trans women are women, trans men can be pregnant, and non binary people can need an abortion. Identification is not about the plumbing, it is the totality of the entire package making a person who they are. IMO. Hugs

    Liked by 5 people

Speak!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s