Caution: You’re Gonna Be Trickled-Down On!

Could the GOP’s current tax plan be the tax cut that causes a recession?

It’s a great question. And the House plan provides plenty to be worried about in that regard. Take, for instance, the proposed elimination of the deductibility of state and local taxes. That is obviously a cynical, politically motivated ploy on Donald Trump’s part to penalize voters who didn’t vote for him (for good reason) in high-tax blue states, such as New York and California, and to give a benefit to the red-state voters who did vote for him. (I get it, elections have consequences.) Eliminating the deductibility of state and local taxes is an incredibly divisive plan. “It’s a transfer to red-state wealthy guys,” said the executive, who lives in a blue state.

Worse, he says, it could lead to another housing crisis, just as the last one is (or should be) still fresh in our collective memories. Here’s his thinking (which is hard to refute): Since, generally speaking, one of the largest state taxes is on property—your home—eliminating the federal tax deduction for state property taxes will inevitably cause the cost of homeownership in states with high property taxes to go up. It follows, logically, that if the annual cost of home ownership goes up, then the value of the home—which is for most people their single most-valuable asset—must go down. The National Association of Realtors commissioned a recent study that predicted that the elimination of the deduction for state and local taxes could result in a decrease in home valuations of between 10 percent and 17 percent.

That would wipe out a huge amount of homeowner equity, with the usual expected consequences: the sick feeling that comes from knowing that suddenly you are poorer, which can then lead to lower consumer spending, kicking off a recession. Furthermore, if the value of homes goes down, then whatever equity has been built up in those homes will also go down, and the ability to unlock that equity—through home-equity loans or reverse mortgages—will also decrease. Lower home values could also lead to problems—again—for the government-sponsored entities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac that have guaranteed some home mortgages, which are secured by homes worth materially less. New problems for the G.S.E.s will make it harder for people to get mortgages, leading to a lower level of home ownership than already exists.

It’s Vanity Fair, and it is a great read.

This entry was posted in tax reform, Taxes. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Caution: You’re Gonna Be Trickled-Down On!

  1. This is the drown them in the bathtub Austerity ratchet in action.

    Cut taxes, blow up the defiicit, reduce spending. If you blow up the economy, well a whole lotta people will have to sell stuff at fire sale prices and will work for less. The 0.01% swoops in snaps it all up and gets ready for the next clicking of the ratchet. Look at what happened to all that foreclosed housing…it got snapped up by Wall Street and is rentals now, and breaking more people donw from middle to lower class will only increase that market.

    Fundamentally the 0.01% don’t care about blowing up the economy; they get bailed out so there’s no downside for them. This is what happens when your capitalist oligarchs look at the Heath Ledger Joker and think to themselves, “Hey there’s a good business model!” Ferdwgssake some of them are literally vampires!

    We’re gonna need a LOT of guillotines.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pat Day says:

    The problem is they BELIEVE this shyte. They won’t find out the damage until they pass the tax cut, middle class goes to Hell in a recycled hand-basket, Big Ass recession hits, too late for a correction, blame it on the Democrats because they weren’t supportive (so we can blame half of it on them). Fuck them!!


  3. roket says:

    The next one won’t be just a simple recession. With this tax plan expect a full-blown depression.

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.